CulturalInfluencesontheFormandUseofNegationBetweenEnglishandChinese

CulturalInfluencesontheFormandUseofNegationBetweenEnglishandChinese

Abstract:Negationisauniversallinguisticphenomenonforalmostallthelanguagesintheworld.Differentlanguageshavedifferentwaystoexpressnegation.Inthisarticle,theauthoranalyzestheculturalinfluencesontheformanduseofnegationbetweenEnglishandChineselanguages,soastoputsomeemphasisontheimportanceofcultureinfluencesinlanguageresearchandhelppeopleuselanguagesproperlyandaccurately.

Keywords:negationlanguageculturalinfluences

Languageistheprincipalmeanswherebyweconductourlivesandbelongstoatypicalsymbolthatrecordsandexpressesdifferentcultures.History,worldview,beliefs,values,religions,andsocialorganizationmayallbereflectedthroughdifferentlanguagesandlinguisticvarietiesinaculture.Languageisareflectionofculture.Sothelinguisticdifferencesareduetotherelativeculturaldifferencesandinfluences.Negationisauniversallinguisticphenomenonforalmostallthelanguagesintheworld.Differentlanguageshavedifferentwaystoexpressnegation.Negationisdefinedas“theabsenceoroppositeofsomepositivethingorquality”intheWorldBookDictionaryandinChinese“否定”isdefinedas“否定事物的存在或事物的真实性;表示否认的,反面的”.FollowingitwilldescribetheculturalinfluencesontheformanduseofnegationinEnglishandChinese.Andthentheimportanceofculturewillbeemphasizedinlanguageuse.

1.CulturalInfluencesontheFormofNegation

Culturehasgreatinfluenceuponlanguage.InEnglishandChinese,negationisalsoinfluencedbytwoculturesandespeciallyontheformofnegation.ChineseculturebelongstoHCcultureandEnglishculturebelongstoLCculture.In1976EdwardT.Halldefinedthetwoterms—HCandLCasthefollowing:“Ahighcontext(HC)communicationormessage”istheoneinwhichmostoftheinformationisalreadyintheperson,whileverylittleisinthecoded,explicitlytransmittedpartofthemessage.LCisjusttheopposite.SobecauseEnglishculturebelongstoLCcultureandChineseculturebelongstoHCculture,EnglishishypotacticandChineseisparatactic,EnglishismorepersethanChineseinnegativewords.Forexample,Englishnegativewordslikenot,no,never,hardly,seldom,few,nor,none,etc.andtheformsin3.3.IncontrasttoEnglish,thecommonnegativewordsinChineseare不(adv.),没(有)(adv./v.)and别(adv.).AndEnglishismorecomplexthanChineseinnegativestructures.Englishlanguageisalphabetic,sotheEnglish-speakingpeoplelikeabstractthinking,whichcausesexpressingthemselveswithcomplexstructures.Chinesecharactersarepictographicandideographic,andtheChinese-speakingpeoplearegoodatthinkingintermsofimage.Astothenegativestructure,EnglishnegationismorecomplicatedthanChinesenegation.Forexample,thestructureof‘not+all’canbepartiallynegatedandsometimescanbeabsolutelynegated.Forexample:Allthefriendsaren’tattheparty.Itmayhavetwomeanings:并不是所有的朋友都来参加聚会了or所有的朋友都没有来参加聚会.InChinesesentences,it’scleartodistinguishpartialnegationandabsolutenegation,forexample,全班同学今天都没有按时上课isanabsolutenegationand并不是全班同学今天都按时上课isapartialnegation.

2.CulturalInfluencesontheUseofNegation

Languageisthecarrierofculture.Culturehasgreatinfluenceonlanguagenotonlyintermsofformbutalsointermsofuse.Therefore,thereareculturalinfluencesontheuseofnegationinEnglishandChinese.

(1)InWesterncountries,English-speakingpeopleusetheaffirmativewaytoexpressanegativeresponse,andthenegativewaytoconfirmanegativestatement.Forexample,

a:A:Heisn’tfromChina,ishe?

B:Yes,heis.

b.A:Heisn’tfromChina,ishe?

B:No,heisn’t.

InEnglish,theresponsetothenegativestatementisinaccordancewiththecorrespondingstatement.Ifthestatementispositive,yesisusedandifthestatementisnegative,noisused.ButinChinese,peoplewillusetheaffirmativewaytoconfirmanegativestatement,andthenegativewaytodenyanegativestatement.Theanswerdependsonpeople’sattitudestowardsthequestionitself.That’stosay,ifyouagreetotheideasandyousay“yes”;ifnotthenyousay“no”.TheChineserelativeresponsestotheformerexampleare:

a.A:他不来自于中国,是不是?

B:不,他来自中国。

b.A:他不来自于中国,是不是?

B:是的,他不来自中国。

SobecausedifferentcustomsandthinkingmodesexistedinEnglishandChinese,peoplewillusedifferentevenoppositeanswerstoexpresstheirmeaningsofyesornoontheuseofnegation.

(2)InWesterncountries,peopleoftenhavethethoughtofequality.Theyliketotreatothersasequalsandprefertobetreatedinthesamemanner.Theypayenoughattentiononequalitythathasbeenthepublicprinciple.Ifusingsomepublictoolssuchasadvertisements,newspapers,etc.togiveawarning,theyoftenuseapositivewayandspeakinasmoothandsoftmanner.Forexample,theEnglish-speakingpeopleoftenusethesentence“Keepoffthegrass”toremindthepassers-bynottowalkonthegrass.

Chinesepeopleoftentendtobeself-centered,andChinesepeoplewilladoptastrong-wordedstatement,usuallyuseanegativewayandexpresssomethingdirectlyandrigidly.Foeexample,inordertodescribethewarningthatremindsthepassers-bynottowalkonthegrass,Chinesewilldirectlyuse勿踏草坪(Don’twalkonthegrass)towarnpeople.People’swaysofspeakingandthinkingpatternsaredifferentareduetotheirdifferentculturalbackground.Therefore,theuseoflanguagesalsohasgreatlyinfluencedbythecultureandhasmanydifferences.

(3)InpidualismistheprincipleandthoughtofpeopleinWesterncountries.English-speakingpeopleareopen,frankandhonest.Theyaredirectinspeechandtheyuseyesornotoexpresstheirinpidualopinionsdirectly.TheChinesepeopletendtobesituation-oriented.Theymayseempassiveandaskalotofquestionsorprobeforinformation.Inactuality,theyarerelatingeacheventtothesituationandtryingtoviewittotally(Samovar,1995:231).SoChinesepeoplewilluseyesfornoandnoforyestoavoidhurting.Theuseofindirectnesshelpstopreventtheembarrassmentofrejectionbytheotherpeopleordisagreementamongpartners,leavingtherelationshipandthefaceofeachpartyintact.Sotheuseoflanguageisdeeplyaffectedbytheculturalinfluence.

Languageisasetofsymbolsandtherulesforcombiningthosesymbolsthatareusedandunderstoodbyalargecommunityofpeople.Languageispartoftheculture.Thereisnooneaspectofhumanlifethatisnottouchedandalteredbyculture.Theoriginoflinguisticdifferencesistheculturaldifferences.Culturereflectsandaffectslanguage.SothedifferencesontheformanduseofnegationbetweenEnglishandChineseareduetodifferentculturalbackgrounds.

3.TheImportanceofCulture

Cultureiseverywhere.Alltheexperience,education,languageandsooncreatedbyhumankindareregardedasculture,whateveritiscomprehensiveoneslikeworld-outlook,space-timeoutlook,philosophy,andvalueetc.oritisconcreteoneslikebasicnecessitiesoflife,marriageandfuneral.Allthesesociallifestyle,behavior,hierarchy,normandmoralandsoonallbelongtoculture.Culturehasmaterialcultureandnonmaterialculture.Materialculturereferstotangibleitemssuchascars,watches,televisionsets,andhorses.Nonmaterialculturecontainsintangibleelementssuchasvalues,norms,beliefs,emotions,attitudes,aspirations,lawsandsymbols.

Cultureisthedepositofknowledge,experience,beliefs,values,actions,attitudes,meanings,hierarchies,religion,notionsoftime,roles,spatialrelations,conceptsoftheuniverse,andartifactsacquiredbyagroupofpeopleinthecourseofgenerationsthroughinpidualandgroupstriving.Shapirooncesaidthediscoveryofculture,theawarenessthatitshapesandmoldsourbehavior,ourvaluesandevenourideas,therecognitionthatitcontainssomeelementofthearbitrary,canbeastartlingoranilluminatingexperience.Cultureislearned:frominfancy,peopleneedtolearntheirpatternsofbehaviorandwaysofthinkingintheircultures.Differentcultureswillproduceandcreatedifferentrules,beliefsandbehaviors.Atthesametime,culturesaredynamicsystemsthatdonotexistinavacuum,sotheyaresubjecttochange.Cultureischangingandit’simportanttoknowandstudyculturetoavoidmakingmistakesinpeople’slife.

What’smoreimportantisthatcultureisbasedonsymbols,especiallybasedonlanguage.Theemergenceoflanguagewasthegiantstepthatmadepossibletheremarkableandintricatesystemwecallculture.Ananthropologistsaidthathumanculturewithoutlanguageisunthinkable.Languagethusenablespeopletocommunicatewhattheywoulddoifsuch-and-suchhappened,toorganizetheirexperiencesintoabstractcategories,andtoexpressthoughtsneverspokenbefore(BatesandPlog).Becauselanguageisareflectionofcultureandlanguageisaffectedbyculture,sotheimportanceofcultureshouldbenoticedandemphasized.Culturefunctionsasanintegratedwholeandissystemic.Allinall,cultureneedstobepaidmuchmoreattentiontoandcultureisimportant.

Negationisauniversallinguisticphenomenonforalmostallthelanguagesintheworldandisimportantaswellasfrequentineverydaysocialinteractions.WhenpeoplearetryingtorecognizetheformofnegationandeventouseitinEnglishorinChinese,pleasedonotforgettopayspecialattentiontotheculturaldifferencesandinfluencesbetweeneachother,becauseanylanguageisareflectionofculture.Onlycanyourealizetheimportanceofculturalinfluences,peoplewillimprovetheirwayofusinglanguageproperlyandcorrectly.

References:

1.Lado,R.LinguisticsacrossCulture[M].Michigan:MichiganUniversityPress,1960

2.Salzmann,Z.Language,CultureandSociety[M].Oxford:WestviewPress,1993

3.Jespersen,O.NegationinEnglishandOtherLanguages.London,1917

4.邓炎昌,刘润清.语言与文化-英汉语言文化对比[M].北京:外语教学与研究出版社,1994

5.李瑞华主编.英汉语言文化对比研究.上海:上海外语教育出版社,1999

6.戚雨村.语言对比和文化对比[J].外国语,1992

7.王彬.英汉否定对比研究.哈尔滨工程大学硕士学位论文,2001

8.陈文伯.英汉否定表达法比较.外语教学与研究第2期,1978

个人简介:

朱安莉,女,军事经济学院基础部外语教研室教员;研究方向:比较语言学。

标签:;  ;  ;  

CulturalInfluencesontheFormandUseofNegationBetweenEnglishandChinese
下载Doc文档

猜你喜欢